Billy the Kid John Tunstall Alexander McSween Susan McSween Rob Widenmann Richard Brewer Charlie Bowdre Josiah Scurlock Fred Waite Henry Brown Jose Chavez Frank Coe Tom O'Folliard Gottfried Gauss Saturnino Baca Lawrence Murphy Emil Fritz John Riley James Dolan John Kinney Sheriff William Brady George Peppin Col. Nathan Dudley Jacob Mathews Robert Beckwith John Chisum Thomas Catron Gov. Lew Wallace Sheriff Pat Garrett Judge Warren Bristol Robert Olinger